Believing the strangest things
A few years ago, me and my buddy Mr. Magic did a very small Swedish-speaking podcast where we discussed Bowie’s albums. In the very last episode, we ranked Bowie’s all albums from 28 up to number One.
The bottom five in my list became a fierce dog fight between the two Tin Machine albums, “Pin Ups”, the first album named “David Bowie” and “Tonight”. With that I must say that this album is not great.
“Tonight” was released the year after the smash hit “Let’s Dance”. The reason for the Record Company Man was of course to pull more gold out of the mine. For Bowie it seems to have been an after-thought altogether. He ditched Nile Rodgers as the producer, and the album looks like a support project for his friend Iggy Pop who ran low on cash at the time.
Bowie wrote two new songs with Iggy, Tumble and Twirl and Dancing With the Big Boys, and added three old Iggy songs from the seventies as well as two other covers, one Beach Boys and a Leiber-Stoller song. The rest was a mere two new songs, Loving the Alien and Blue Jean. This is not nearly enough I would say. Bowie continued to surprise his audience, ever the chameleon. He never took the easy way out.
Besides the low output of new "fresh" material, the production of the album is extremely weak. It reeks of bad eighties choices of instruments, mixing and overall “style”. As if that was not enough, many of the songs are done as reggae!!! Hate is a strong word when it comes to reviewing music, so let’s say I really, really don’t like reggae.
In the end only three of the new songs are interesting. “Blue Jean” has a funny music video that is so dated you can only smile with remembrance in your eyes. The best thing with it may be David’s make up. If you are to check it out, don’t miss to also have a look at the 20 minutes short film built around the song directed by Julien Temple.
“Dancing With the Big Boys” is like an early song from the “Never Let Me Down”-sessions. It is bombastic and fun in a way, but it’s not among Bowie’s classics. “Loving the Alien” is better. Reminds me about some of his work for soundtracks like “Absolute Beginners”.
Of the rest, most of them are unbearable to me. Sure, Bowie gives a master class in singing on the “God Only Knows” but I question the need for this song and this album to begin with. One part new stuff, one part covers and one part reggae versions of old Iggy Pop songs. Crazy. Like a “Kinder Surprise”, but without the chocolate.
Maybe I can give him that the album is eclectic at least.
My rating: 3/10
Side A:
1.Loving the Alien
2.Don’t Look Down
3.God Only Knows
4.Tonight
Side B:
1.Neighborhood Threat
2.Blue Jean
3.Tumble and Twirl
4.I Keep Forgettin’
5.Dancing With the Big Boys
Best songs: “Loving the Alien” and “Blue Jean”
Produced by: David Bowie, Derek Bramble and Hugh Padgham
Released on September 24th, 1984
Media: Box “Loving the Alien [1983-1988]”, 2018, reissue, remaster, 180g